Comments Are Not Influence

One challenge facing any long-running publication is deciding how to measure success.

That question has become increasingly relevant as SafetyAtWorkBlog approaches its twentieth anniversary next year. Looking back also requires looking forward, and that means considering what success should look like for a specialist publication operating in a very different media environment from the one in which it began.

In the early years of blogging, success was often measured by comments. A lively comment thread suggested readers were engaged, arguments were being tested, and a community was forming around a publication. Some of the most valuable discussions about occupational health and safety (OHS) occurred beneath articles rather than on social media. That is no longer the case.

The decline in comments is often interpreted as evidence of declining relevance, but that assumption misunderstands how professional audiences now engage with ideas. The conversation has not necessarily disappeared. More often, it has moved elsewhere.

Readers now discuss articles through LinkedIn, Facebook, X, industry forums, emails and private messaging. Many people who regularly read an article will never leave a comment on the originating website. (Some are not permitted to comment due to corporate social media policies) They may share it with colleagues, debate it internally, refer to it during meetings or challenge its conclusions on another platform, all without leaving any visible sign of engagement beneath the original article.

This change creates a problem for publishers. If readers continue reading and sharing content but stop commenting, how should success be measured?

Looking at SafetyAtWorkBlog’s history suggests comments are no longer the most useful metric. The blog has published more than 4,000 articles over almost twenty years and has maintained a consistency that many specialist publications fail to achieve. In that time, the content has also evolved. Short reports on news events have increasingly been replaced by longer examinations of work health and safety regulation, workplace culture, leadership, industrial relations and public policy. The audience appears to have matured, and the writing has matured with it.

Importantly, influence and community are not the same thing. A publication can host an active community but have little impact beyond its own audience. Equally, a publication can shape discussions, influence decision-makers and challenge established thinking while generating relatively little visible interaction on its own platform. For specialist and professional publications, that second form of influence may now matter more.

The more useful question is not how many comments an article receives but whether it is being read, referenced and discussed. Does it contribute to policy debates? Does it challenge accepted assumptions? Does it provide unique information and analysis that readers cannot easily find elsewhere? Does it influence how people think about OHS?

Those questions are harder to answer than simply counting comments, but they are probably better indicators of success.

The decline in blog comments may therefore reveal less about a publication’s quality than about the changing nature of online communication. If anything, the movement of discussion into professional networks may indicate that ideas are being tested where organisational decisions are made, and workplace practices are shaped.

As SafetyAtWorkBlog approaches its twentieth year, that may be the most meaningful measure of success. The blog’s role is no longer primarily to host the conversation, but to start it, promote it, and challenge assumptions.

Maintaining editorial independence, publishing consistently, attracting readers and continuing to contribute to debates about OHS are probably more demanding measures of success than counting comments beneath an article. They are also more valuable.

This year, the SafetyAtWorkBlog readership and visitation stats are at record levels – over 116K views to date with a daily average of 361 views – but inflated by AI trawling. Thankfully, AI is only accessing open access articles and the opening paragraphs. The numbers are comforting, but longevity, relevance and influence are more satisfying.

Whether that remains sustainable is another question entirely.

Kevin Jones

Categories Blog, media, OHS, safety, Uncategorized, WHS

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Concatenate Web Development
© Designed and developed by Concatenate Aust Pty Ltd